left corner inner shadow
right corner inner shadow
Featured topics
Video: Conversation about China
Video: Conversation about China

Qu Hongbin believes investing in infrastructure will help China address its stalled economic growth.

Global Economics Quarterly
Global Economics Quarterly

Group Chief Economist Stephen King and Chief Global Economist Karen Ward explain the potential long-term global impact of monetary stimulus.

See all insights

Featured resources
Treasury World magazine

Treasury World is a magazine for senior executives tasked with optimising their company's finances.

Week in China

Week in China offers exclusive commentary on key business trends emerging from China, updated every week.

Global Research

In-depth economic analysis and advice from a team of global finance experts

Why Global Banking and Markets Why Global Banking and Markets

Global Banking and Markets is a globally connected business, with a strong footprint in emerging markets.

HSBC in the forefront of Offshore RMB Business HSBC in the forefront of Offshore RMB Business

Learn more about the opportunities and risks of the rapidly expanding market for China's currency.

Awards Awards

Many of the industry's leading publications recognise our success as an emerging markets-led and financing-focused wholesale bank.

Careers for experienced candidates
How important are graduates to HSBC?
Experienced candidates

Be part of one of the most respected and internationally connected banks in the world

Is HSBC right for me?

Careers for graduates
Career events
Student and graduate careers

HSBC offers a world of opportunities for individuals at the early stage of their career.

Deflation is 2014's hidden threat

Print

19 Dec 2013
Stephen King, Group Chief Economist

Stephen King

In the US and Europe, in particular, central banks face a troubling dilemma in 2014: should they tighten monetary policy in response to the improved real economy or keep policy loose in response to an increasing threat of deflation?

Disinflation or deflation can reflect a sudden surge in productivity or increase in energy supply that drives down headline inflation. However, these factors don’t fully explain why inflation globally is currently so low. Instead, it seems low inflation reflects the waning powers of central banks, whose unconventional monetary stimulus policies have had a bigger impact on financial asset values than on the real economy.

Rather than removing deflationary trends, monetary stimulus seems merely to allow central banks to export deflation to other parts of the world.

Initial bouts of quantitative easing – whether in the UK, Japan or US – were associated with sizeable exchange rate declines that temporarily lifted inflation in the ‘host’ country. Yet for every exchange rate decline there must inevitably be an exchange rate rise. And for those experiencing ‘unwanted’ gains, inflation has ended up lower than expected and, often, lower than desired. Look at the Eurozone in the second half of 2013.

Normally, this wouldn’t be a problem. But with domestic transmission mechanisms not working as well as they might, and with growing protectionism, one country’s monetary stimulus is increasingly another’s ball and chain. If unconventional policies work primarily through the exchange rate, they serve primarily to export, rather than cure, disinflationary pressures. At the international level, those pressures refuse to subside.

Rather than removing deflationary trends, monetary stimulus seems merely to allow central banks to export deflation to other parts of the world

It is comforting to think low inflation won’t last. However, despite falling unemployment in the US and UK, wage growth remains surprisingly weak. And there is a danger of confusing cause with effect. In a standard economic cycle, activity leads inflation. In a post-bubble environment, where debts are high and deleveraging is rife, the opposite applies: excessively low inflation increases real debt levels, hinders deleveraging and eventually suppresses demand and activity. Japan’s modest mid-1990s recovery was ultimately undermined by creeping deflation and premature policy tightening.

This makes it harder to manage the transition from QE to ‘forward guidance’ as tapering takes hold in the US. But if central banks cannot decide whether output leads inflation or inflation leads output, providing clear advice on future monetary policy may be
near impossible.

It is against this backdrop that we make forecasts for 2015. We expect global growth to accelerate to 2.8% by then – up from 2.0% in 2012 and 2.6% in 2013. The acceleration reflects a shift from Eurozone contraction to modest expansion alongside a more aggressive – although unbalanced – UK pick-up.

At around 2.3% in 2014 and 2.5% in 2015, the forecast pace of US economic recovery remains disappointing. Emerging markets shrug off some of their 2013 funk, returning to growth of above 5% by 2015, but Brazil remains notably weak.

While not predicting a descent into outright deflation there is a risk that inflation remains too low, or even sinks, over the next two years. Japan’s 1990s’ experience demonstrated that a near-term cyclical pick-up in no sense guarantees the deflation genie has been put back in its bottle.

Forward guidance may increasingly have to focus on the dangers associated with inflationary undershoots rather than on growth overshoots, implying interest rates stay low for longer, particularly in the US and the Eurozone.

This report must be read with the disclosures, analyst certifications and the disclaimer.